The tweet that put a Scottsdale sports announcer on a collision course together with his state Senator, Michelle Ugenti-Rita, wasn’t an uncommon one for him.
“You show that you’re a full waste of human flesh with no redeeming valuea [sic] ever time you tweet. Resign you dumb nazi whore,” Josh Miller posted from an nameless Twitter account on January 30.
Miller — who has narrated San Francisco Giants spring coaching video games over the general public handle system since 2003 and whose resume additionally contains work with Grand Canyon College, the Arizona Fall League, and Scottsdale’s Desert Mountain Excessive Faculty — had been making posts like these since no less than November. He repeatedly quote-tweeted Ugenti-Rita from an nameless account known as ZonaJosh, mixing political rhetoric with misogynistic assaults, calling her a “whore,” a “bitch,” and a “twat.”
Ugenti-Rita, a Republican representing District 23, has taken quite a lot of controversial political positions. Amongst different issues, she’s been a critic of the governor’s state of emergency to deal with the COVID-19 pandemic and has pushed to remove people from early-voting lists if they missed elections. She’s change into accustomed to a specific amount of misogynistic vitriol directed her manner on-line.
However the January 30 tweet caught the legislator’s consideration.
“That basically caught me off guard with the vulgarity of the language he was utilizing and the graphic nature of it,” Ugenti-Rita advised Phoenix New Occasions.
Determining who was behind the account did not require a detective. After Ugenti-Rita responded to the January 30 tweet, calling ZonaJosh an nameless “#GutlessCoward,” somebody in the neighborhood messaged her with their suspicions about his id. She did a little bit of sleuthing and found that Miller included his actual first title within the assault account’s ZonaJosh moniker and posted similar pictures and captions to each his private Instagram and the supposedly nameless troll account.
“That may’t be. He wouldn’t be that dumb,” Ugenti-Rita stated she remembers pondering as she pored by means of his social media accounts on a Saturday morning.
She made a submit tagging Miller and requested if the ZonaJosh account was him.
Miller responded and initially denied the accusation. When Ugenti-Rita replied with screenshots exhibiting the similar pictures, he denied it once more however deleted the troll account.
The subsequent day, Miller posted a Notes-app-style apology on Twitter entitled “I Messed Up,” by which he admitted to operating the account. Reached by New Occasions on Thursday, Miller stated he made a mistake and used sturdy language that he should not have.
“That is strictly about her insurance policies, which I believed put a threat to my household and the group,” he stated. Miller stated that as a father or mother, he was annoyed by Ugenti-Rita’s assist of resuming in-person instruction in faculties.
Ugenti-Rita is not shopping for the apology.
“This particular person has a lot deeper issues than faculty closures… this a disturbed particular person who used an nameless account to sexually harass me and others and now could be pissed he bought known as out,” she stated. “This has nothing to do with politics and every part to do together with his habits.”
The episode with Miller additionally contained echoes of a earlier scandal involving Ugenti-Rita and sexist feedback. In 2017, she spoke out about “undesirable sexual advances and lewd and suggestive feedback” she’d obtained on the Legislature and was the primary to accuse former Consultant Don Shooter of misconduct. Shooter was ultimately expelled from the Legislature, and within the aftermath, Ugenti-Rita was accused of sexual harassment herself.
In a single tweet, Miller referenced that scandal, significantly the allegation that Ugenti-Rita’s associate had despatched specific images of her to a lobbyist. An investigation discovered that the images had been despatched with out her consent or information, and a few legislators called for a “revenge porn” investigation.
Miller was much less sympathetic.
“Go ship extra pics of your rotten pussy to your staffers,” he wrote.
Miller denied that his feedback as a complete had been misogynistic, saying he is a father or mother, a husband, and the son of a mom.
“I known as her names. I might not name them misogynistic,” he stated, including that he’d additionally directed completely different insults towards males and that, “I don’t take into account myself a misogynistic particular person.”
Requested if he’d run that argument by any girls in his life, particularly that he hadn’t been misogynistic as a result of he’d additionally focused males, Miller stated this was first time it had come up.
The web drama has since spilled over into the true world. Since Ugenti-Rita posted about him on Fb and Twitter, Miller stated that he’d obtained messages from her supporters and that a few of them had contacted his employers. His web site lists upcoming occasions with the Scottsdale Unified Faculty District and the San Francisco Giants.
“Issues are pending so I can’t get into it,” Miller stated, concerning the standing of these gigs.
Ugenti-Rita and her supporters on Fb have additionally glommed on to a submit by which Miller inspired safety on the U.S. Capitol to shoot and kill rioters in January.
“I’m working with [the Scottsdale school district]. We’ll see what occurs. He additionally made some posts encouraging violence. Based mostly on his habits, I consider he’s a hazard. I’m very involved about his interactions with our youngsters,” Ugenti-Rita wrote on Fb alongside a screenshot of the submit. She inspired one other supporter to succeed in out to Miller and “let him understand how you are feeling about his habits,” posting an inventory of his upcoming saying gigs from his web site.
When New Occasions identified the context of Miller’s remarks — that the tweet was in reference to the storming of the U.S. Capitol by a violent mob — Ugenti-Rita stated that he was nonetheless inciting violence.
“Any time you advocate for violence, it’s alarming,” she stated.
A few of Ugenti-Rita’s followers appear taken with the thought of “canceling” somebody on the alternative aspect of the political spectrum.
“I am not into cancel tradition, and I do know you are not both, however I *am* into exposing hypocrisy. And for that motive alone, cancelling him is the one technique to get by means of to his variety,” wrote one commenter. “However that might require integrity from these on the cancelling aspect, which is an oxymoron, so I will not maintain my breath.”
Scottsdale Unified Faculty District spokesperson Nancy Norman stated that the matter is being investigated however she couldn’t say the rest at this level. The Giants didn’t reply to requests for remark Thursday.
Ugenti-Rita stated that it is easy to try to ignore on-line harassment, however it’s a must to stand as much as bullies to get them to cease. She hopes this shall be an instance to different girls: If she hadn’t stated something, Miller would nonetheless be smearing her on-line.
“However he attacked the flawed lady,” she stated.
Miller known as the posts a poor alternative and stated he was simply blowing off steam. He thinks he deserves a second probability.
“It was a job I used to be taking part in,” he stated. “It was only a troll account…. I don’t consider it defines me.”
Maintain Phoenix New Occasions Free… Since we began Phoenix New Occasions, it has been outlined because the free, impartial voice of Phoenix, and we wish to hold it that manner. Providing our readers free entry to incisive protection of native information, meals and tradition. Producing tales on every part from political scandals to the most well liked new bands, with gutsy reporting, fashionable writing, and staffers who’ve received every part from the Society of Skilled Journalists’ Sigma Delta Chi feature-writing award to the Casey Medal for Meritorious Journalism. However with native journalism’s existence underneath siege and promoting income setbacks having a bigger impression, it’s important now greater than ever for us to rally assist behind funding our native journalism. You may assist by taking part in our “I Assist” membership program, permitting us to maintain protecting Phoenix with no paywalls.